The Ethical Dilemma Faced By The Managers At The Law Firm

1. How would you describe the ethical dilemma confronted by the managers at the law firm? The ethical dilemma was choosing either to respect Andrew’s condition or to take care of the health and interests of the rest of the employees. The latter option meant that Andrew had to be dismissed due his condition (suffering from a deadly disease and being homosexual). The ethical dilemma arose because the company had to compromise other factors and make a decision of firing Andrew based on others requests. They chose to leave aside his services as an amazing lawyer, thought that by doing so, they would be isolated from contagion of HIV. 2. Are the managers at Wyant Wheeler justified in firing Andrew? What set of criteria would you use to arrive at this decision? No. The managers at Wyant and Wheeler were not justified to fire Andrew. Andrew, being a brilliant lawyer knew that it was his legal right to keep his HIV status secret to himself. The firm’s main reason for firing Andrew was because of panic. The managers feared the deadly disease. However, they discriminated against Andrew by firing him merely because of his condition. Instead of firing Andrew, the managers should have adopted a better way of protecting the rest of the employees from contracting the disease. 3. How is the fact that Andrew concealed his illness relevant to the case? The fact that Andrew concealed his illness is relevant to the case because of the worries he had about the stigmas. HeShow MoreRelatedManagerial Ethics: Enron Case Study1392 Words   |  6 Pagesand the principals were prosecuted. There is, in essence, no real ethical dilemma in the Enron case. A true ethical dilemma would have a dilemma component, whereas Enron was outright criminal behavior from the outset. Nevertheless, we will use this example to discuss some of the issues in managerial ethics. Theoretical Frameworks There are a number of different theoretical frameworks that have been proposed to evaluate ethical decision-making in business. Most of these are loosely based on philosophicalRead MoreEthical Dilemma Case1021 Words   |  5 PagesCASE ANALYSIS: Should we go beyond the law I. Ethical dilemma †¢ Nathan Rosillo is faced with an ethical dilemma. It seems that the river is the company’s least concern in its effort to make profit again. Here are the following issues that need to be addressed in this ethical problem: o First and foremost, standards from regulatory agency were loosened in such a way that wastes can now be directly dumped into Dutch Valle River. Nathan, finds dumping of wasteRead MoreEssay about Easy1652 Words   |  7 Pagesprogram or purchase one offered by a consulting firm, the manager must consider several different factors. First, the manager must consider the costs associated with both options. Is the cost of labor to create the program less than the cost of purchasing one by a consulting firm? Which option yields a better return on investment? Second, the manager needs to determine how quickly the program needs to be implemented. Purchasing a program from a consulting firm may be the quickest alternative. However,Read MoreEnron - Ethical Dilemma Essay1129 Words   |  5 PagesEthical decision making: A dilemma Ethical issues have greatly transformed in our lives since the great Enron, Xerox and other huge corporations proposed big profits showing earnings of billions of dollars and yet in reality facing bankruptcy. These corporations faced great trouble with the federals and state for manipulating financial statements. But not only corporations can be blamed on this, accounting firms were involved in this as much as the corporations were. With the business standRead MoreCase Analysis : The Case Of Dr. J. T, Merck, And Co.1535 Words   |  7 Pagescurrency risk. Depending on the country a business is established, the risks vary in the type, occurrence and impact. Merck Sharp and Dohme Argentine, MSD, the subsidiary of a U.S based pharmaceutical company, Merck and Co., faced lots of such challenges. Antonio Mosquera faced a lot of country risks and obstacles. Country risk is the adverse effect on a company’s operations due the host country’s political, legal and economic deve lopments. For instance, there were inadequate and underdeveloped rulesRead MoreEthical Challenges Faced By Ibm1010 Words   |  5 PagesA technological company can be faced with various kinds of moral challenges. Usually all companies have the responsibility to provide services on behalf of other companies or clients. It may be reasonable that any unethical decision or approaches made by a company is being represented by some other firms. In the case of IBM, the IBM Company is best known for developing computer systems, hardware, software, and infrastructure. Founded in 1911, the company remains well known as one of the most popularRead MoreCompetitive Intelligence Predicament1047 Words   |  5 PagesCOMPETITIVE INTELLIGENCE PREDICAMENT Problem Statement †¢ Miguel Vasquez, a new product manager for a biotechnology company, was handed with some competitive intelligence from another competing firm. †¢ The said information, handed to him by his boss, contained proprietary and confidential information that can give a competitive advantage to the firm. †¢ This information was obviously obtained using an illegal tap into the competing firm’s servers. †¢ With no clear policy on matters that pertainRead MoreEnrons Business Ethics Failure1485 Words   |  6 PagesContent 1. Overview ............................................................................................3 2. The Fall of Enron ...............................................................................4 3. Enrons ethical dilemmas ..................................................................6 4. Conslucions .......................................................................................7 5. Bibliography .....................................................Read MoreThe Triple Bottom Line: the People, the Planet, and the Profits818 Words   |  4 PagesPeople: Ethical Leadership Considerations and Recommendations One of the most overlooked components of the 3BL is the portion concerned with ethical decision-making and leadership within an organization. The ethics of a company are a direct reflection of the values and morals that are embodied in a company; a company cannot claim to be an employee-friendly organizations while its policies and procedures are designed to unfairly exploit the workforce. Ethical leadership is one way in which a companyRead MoreAuditing Assignment1425 Words   |  6 Pages------------------------------------------------- Total Word Count: 1250 ------------------------------------------------- This case study will analyse the ethical dilemmas faced by David, audit manager at C A who is hired to do the financial year-end audit for MAL. The six step ethical framework will be adopted to gain an understanding of principles and obligations for analysing the situation faced by David and arrive to a professional and responsible resolution. Step 1: Relevant Facts of the Case MAL-Marburg Appliances